Cowboyway Home Page

Cowboyway Home Page

DISCLOSURE: This page might contain affiliate links. / Photo Of The Day

Homemade Cat Treats

Recipes for homemade cat treats abound on the Web.

However, when looking for homemade cat treat recipes we noticed that few, if any, of the sites mentioned if they'd actually made the treats themselves, or if they'd ever given them to their cats to see if they liked them.

So, here at we made one of the most common recipes for homemade cat treats that we found, then gave the treats to four felines to see what they thought about them.

The recipe and details on how the kitties liked them are below.

Below: Two cats taste test homemade cat treats.

Two cats testing homemade cat treats

Cheesy Homemade Cat Treat Ingredients

Makes approximately 50 - 55 treats (depending on how big you cut the pieces).


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. Combine the cheeses and the yogurt (or sour cream), then add the flour and cornmeal.
  3. Add enough water to create a workable dough.
  4. Form the dough into a ball, then roll out to a square or rectangle 1/4 inch thick.
  5. Cut into one inch sized pieces and place on a greased cookie sheet.
  6. Bake approximately 25 minutes.

Cat Treat Photos

The ingredients: Yogurt, shredded cheddar cheese, cornmeal, flour, and grated Parmesan cheese. Not shown: water.

Homemade cat treat recipe ingredients


The shredded cheddar cheese, grated Parmesan cheese, and yogurt.

Shredded cheese, Parmesan cheese, and yogurt


The finished dough after adding the flour, cornmeal and water, then formed into a ball.

Cat treat recipe dough ball


The ball of dough rolled out to about 1/4 inch thick, then cut into 1 inch pieces.

Cat treat recipe dough


Into the oven, ready to bake.

Cat treats ready to bake


After 25 minutes of baking, these were the finished cat treats. They puffed up during baking, and had to be re-cut. They were firm on the outside, and chewy/spongy on the inside.

Baked cat treats

Testing The Homemade Cat Treats

These are the cat treats. They're about as big around as quarter, and a little over 1/4 inch thick.

The finished cat treats


This is Eenie. He's a good sport about pretty much anything, and he was the first one to test the treats. He seemed to think they were awkward to bite into, but after giving one several test bites he ate it.

Eenie eating a treat


Lemur (left) joined Eenie for the treat testing.

Two cats investigate the treats


After several test licks, Lemur (left) ate a treat.

A gray and white cat eats a treat


Then Lemur (left) and Eenie (right) ate a few more treats.

Two cats eating treats


Snack Kitty originally came up to the treats and sniffed them, but then she wandered off a few feet and turned her back on them.

A cat with her back turned


Lemur (shown) and Eenie both seemed to enjoy cleaning up the crumbs.

A gray and white cat licks up cat treat crumbs


The Treat Verdict Is.....

After a few more days of giving these homemade cat treats to our cats, their reactions to the them remained pretty much the same.

Two of the cats, Eenie and Lemur, seemed to like the treats. They didn't love them or go crazy for them, but seemed to think they were OK.

One of the cats, Mo (not seen in the photos above) liked the treats less than Eenie and Lemur did, but would occasionally eat one. Snack Kitty didn't seem to like them at all.

So, at our house the treats were liked, but not loved, by three out of four cats. Not bad odds for finicky felines, but we may try a different cat treat recipe next time. If we do, we'll let you know how it turns out.

More Recipes

Apple Salad

Blended Frozen Bananas

Cat Treats

Ultimate Banana Bread


FREE Newsletter!
Receive tips, how-to's, and other good stuff. Subscribe now!

Some images and/or other content on this website are copyright © their respective owners.
All other material copyright © 1999 - 2024 by - All Rights Reserved

Menu    About / Contact    Newsletter

Disclosures    Privacy Policy